News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Horse killer enrages magistrate 

Horse killer enrages magistrate

14/05/2008 7:53:00 AM
HORSES lay dying on Khodi Ali's Knowsley property, hair rubbed back to bleeding bare skin, and he never did anything to stop it.

Appearing before Bendigo Magistrates Court yesterday, the 39-year-old was charged with aggravated cruelty, failing to provide sufficient food to a horse causing death; failing to provide sufficient food to a horse; failing to provide veterinary care and treatment to a foal; and failing to provide sufficient food to a foal.

RSPCA prosecutor Jason Nichols told the court that following reports, inspectors Mark Roberts and Danielle Hughes visited Ali's home on February 28.

The court heard the inspectors found paddocks bare of feed, four dead horses, and the property covered in faeces.

Several horses still alive were given ratings according to the Huntington Scale, where zero is very poor and five relates to an animal being very fat.

The court heard two mares were given ratings of one, both showing visible hips, spines and ribs, with hollows along their flanks and rumps.

One foal received a score of one, the animal showing deformed forelegs that splayed out at an angle.

Mr Nichols said Ali informed officers he had only provided two small bales of feed to the horses during the previous week as he didn't have any money.

The court heard one week later inspectors attended the property after Ali phoned and said a horse was down, unable to get up.

Mr Nichols said Inspector Roberts found a mare lying on the ground with her foal still attempting to suckle.

The mare was unable to stand and the hair on her underside had been rubbed back to bleeding bare skin.

The horse was euthanased by RSPCA officers.

The following day Inspector Roberts returned to Ali's property with a veterinarian who examined some of the remaining horses.

The court heard Dr Judith Mulholland said one horse displayed a score less than one on the scale.

"She would have been in severe pain and distress while she was on the ground.

"She would have suffered a slow and painful death from dehydration and hunger had she been left in that position."

Other horses were described as being physically unable to compete for limited feed on the property.

Mr Nichols said when asked why the horses were in such poor condition, Ali said he was unable to afford the costs associated with animal maintenance.

"I've got no money. I'm going through a bad stage in my life," Ali said.

The court heard Ali had never treated his horses for worms and a veterinarian had never been called to examine their injuries.

Defence lawyer Robert Thyssen told Magistrate William Gibb Ali was employed over the years in concreting and as a brickies' labourer, but now received Centrelink assistance as a result of a spinal injury.

Mr Thyssen told the court his client was breeding the horses to be sold as pets, and was the father of five children. Ali's wife is also pregnant.

The defence told Mr Gibb photos dated March 21 showed additional feed on the property, ready to be distributed.

"As far as these hapless animals are concerned, it's too little too late," Mr Gibb replied.

Adjourning the court to allow evidence to "wash over him", Mr Gibb said he needed time to deliver his verdict.

He told Ali the paddocks in which he kept the horses were devoid of grass.

"There was nothing to eat unless you provided it. There was nothing to drink unless you provided it."

Photographs tendered to the court enraged the magistrate.

"To look at these photographs of this foal nudging its dying mother is pathetic," he said.

Mr Gibb said while he believed the court should impose a jail term, "to lock you away would impact probably more profoundly on your family."

Ali was convicted and sentenced to six months' imprisonment, suspended for two years.

He was fined $5500 and disqualified from owning horses for four years.

Send to a Friend
Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

Comments


A fine of $5500?, he will claim to have no money and get off free! He should be in Jail living on bread and water. (a little of his own medicine)
Posted by Terry of Central Vic on 14/05/2008 8:19:20 AM
This makes me sick! So what if you're broke, sell the horses before they get sick and starve to death and start breeding again once you have the money.

As for missing out on a jail term because he has family, who cares, he should be jailed for his poor treatment of animals, if he gets away with this it's just showing that the law isn't tough enough on people committing acts of animal cruelty.

$5500 and being disqualified from owning horses for four years is NOT ENOUGH!

It's not going to deter people from committing acts of animal cruelty! If he is so broke, why is he having another child? I hope he can afford to feed his child!

Posted by Little Patch on 14/05/2008 10:02:24 AM
hmmm yeah so broke he can afford a defence lawyer! They should throw away the key... This makes a mockery of the whole system. Law enforcement need be means tested?

if you do the crime you should have to do the time. Maybe they should confiscate his land or something that is going to be of significant consequence to him?

Posted by rjds on 14/05/2008 2:35:27 PM
As an adult, learn to take responsibility for your actions.

Absolutely disgraceful, that these animals have to pay for your laziness and futile excuses.

Bendigo has a huge community spirit, and help would have been provided to ensure these dependent animals a existence.

Very, very disappointed at such a pathetic slap on the wrist.

Posted by Kedge on 14/05/2008 4:27:18 PM
This is a joke, I own horses and they are fed before I eat.

This man should be in jail. How can you have five children and another on the way and say you have no money?

What about that poor foal trying to drink to survive while its mother is dying at the hands of this cruel man?

He should be in jail and that's all there is to it.

Make an example as this happens too much.

If you can't feed them don't own them. Any animal, not just horses, rely on us to survive.

Posted by monaro on 14/05/2008 4:54:43 PM
This sentence is totally inadaquate and Mr Ali should never, ever be allowed to own horses again.
Posted by mary on 15/05/2008 6:00:58 AM
By the sounds of it, this man's family would fair better if he were locked up and treated in the same inhumane manner.

A fine for a man with no money, how ironic, how about unpaid community work, it caters for people with disabilities as well.

Make him really pay for what he has done. He should be banned from owning any animal for life!!!!

Posted by Mitch on 15/05/2008 7:39:08 AM
It all gets back to the pathetic magistrates we get. They sound off ferociously then give a tap on the wrist.
Posted by kevin on 15/05/2008 10:25:11 AM
WHAT A JOKE... this man WILL DO THIS AGAIN
Posted by Me on 15/05/2008 10:37:13 PM
What an example of such a pathetic man and just as pathetic a sentence to go with it.

He really deserves to be treated the way he treated these defenceless animals.

Posted by Ollie on 15/05/2008 11:42:11 PM
1 | 2  | next >

Post A Comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
HORSE KILLER: Khodi Ali outside Bendigo Magistrates Court yesterday.
HORSE KILLER: Khodi Ali outside Bendigo Magistrates Court yesterday.

11:13 AM AEST | Farewell to the Clouseau of foreign ministers: pompous, slightly ridiculous and self-important.
Bendigo Access Employment
 
Innes Motors
 
Best Employment
 
fox personnel
 
Ron Poyser
 
 
LaTrobe University
 
MyCareer